Toppers Pizza

Located at 1102 N 8th St in Sheboygan, WI, Toppers Pizza is a standout destination for pizza aficionados and fast food enthusiasts alike. Specializing in pizza, chicken wings, and catering services, Toppers delivers a vibrant dining experience whether you choose to dine in, pick up, or have your meal delivered right to your doorstep.

Step inside Toppers Pizza and you'll immediately notice the lively, welcoming atmosphere that matches the energy of their fresh, flavorful menu. From the first bite, it’s clear that this isn’t your average pizza joint. The crisp, expertly crafted crusts serve as the perfect foundation for bold toppings and rich sauce blends.

Signature offerings like the Buffalo Chicken Topper Pizza and the indulgent Buffalo Mac & Cheese showcase Toppers’ ability to blend comfort food classics with inventive toppings, creating deeply satisfying flavor profiles that linger on the palate. For those craving a savory twist, the Smoky BBQ and Ragin Pepperoni Pizza deliver smoky, spiced perfection, while the Veggie Classic Pizza provides a vibrant, fresh option bursting with garden flavors.

Chicken wing lovers will find plenty to savor here too—whether it’s the crispy and juicy Half Pound Boneless Chicken Wings with BBQ sauce or the fiery Boneless Hot Wings. Each wing is cooked to tender, saucy excellence, offering that perfect balance of heat and flavor.

For those wanting to customize their meal, Toppers’ “Build Your Own 'Za” option allows a personalized pizza crafted with your choice of crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings. The Pesto Margherita—a standout nut- and cheese-free pesto base topped with 100% Wisconsin mozzarella and garlic-roasted tomatoes—is a fresh, aromatic delight, and even has dairy-free options for vegan patrons. A recent addition, the New Caulipower® King, layers homemade sauce with rich Wisconsin mozzarella and pepper jack, finished with an abundance of pepperoni, offering a hearty and cheesy indulgence.

Beyond the fantastic food offerings, what truly sets Toppers Pizza apart is its friendly, attentive staff and the genuine care they infuse into every order. Customers continually praise the high quality and consistency, with Brian Will noting a perfect "10/10" experience across multiple visits. Manager Ethaniel frequently earns shout-outs for not just preparing incredible pies but delivering warm service, reinforcing Toppers’ reputation as a community favorite.

One of the most heartwarming touches is the care put into presentation—even when ordering online, customers like Rebecca Kubetz report receiving pizzas delivered with personalized notes and cheerful messages written on the boxes, a small gesture that “truly made our day.” This personal flair enhances the overall experience, transforming a simple meal into a moment of joy and connection.

If you’re in Sheboygan and searching for an inviting spot to enjoy pizza that goes beyond the ordinary, Toppers Pizza offers a perfect combination of mouthwatering flavors, variety, and thoughtful service. Whether you’re craving a loaded classic like the Meat Pizza, the indulgent Raspberry Cheesecake Monkey Bread dessert, or a quick, satisfying wing and soda combo, Toppers promises a memorable experience that keeps customers coming back for more.